As concerns around data privacy in machine learning grow, the ability to unlearn—or remove—specific data points from trained models becomes increasingly important. While state-of-the-art unlearning methods have emerged in response, they typically treat all points in the forget set equally. In this work, we challenge this approach by asking: do points that have a negligible impact on the model’s learning need to be removed? Through a comparative analysis of influence functions across language and vision tasks, we identify subsets of training data with negligible impact on model outputs…